Let me go on record as saying that I believe Advent Conspiracy is a great idea, a noble and worthy effort, and something our family is going to take part in this year. As we are discussing the specifics of how our family can Worship Fully, Spend Less, Give More and Love All, I have gotten some resistance to the process. The resistance does not come from our kids or other family members, it comes from my own heart. There are probably many ways to describe what I mean, but the easiest way to describe it is to say: I want stuff.
I want new clothes. I want a new home computer. I want a welder. I want to go out to eat more. I want a Blu-Ray player. I want a new camera.
I want and want and want some more. And this whole “Advent Conspiracy” idea is going to limit me getting what I want. Now the truth is that I wouldn’t get many of those things for Christmas anyway, except for the clothes (my mom can always be counted on to buy me a nice sweater). But does anyone else see the problem here? While none of the things I want are wrong or theologically incorrect, they pale in comparison to the larger good. When I hold up the idea of a family getting fresh water to my Blu-Ray player, I am willing to watch movies in the regular format. I can borrow a friend’s welder for a long time before I buy one if it means that the poor and hurting get something extra this year. The fact that I even view the giving up of these things as “sacrifice” is indicative of how far my heart can stray from one of generosity and compassion.
With kids especially, it’s tough to know how to take part in this in a meaningful way that builds value and doesn’t steal joy. It will be easy to give lip service to the ideas behind the Advent Conspiracy, while still spending as much as we always do, giving the same as we always give and getting lost in the commercial aspects of Christmas more than the true meaning. And it will be easy because that is what everyone is expecting us to do, wanting us to do and what the Christmas season in the western hemisphere is designed to do. But what if, just for this one year, we decided that the problem wasn’t how the kids will respond, or what mom will say, or what our sibling will think about getting a homemade gift? What if we admitted that we have a picture of what we want Christmas to look like and we are unwilling to relinquish that vision? Maybe, like me, you will find the enemy of doing good this year very close to home. I am the problem, but I don’t want to be. How about you?
Written by Steve Musto


